COVID-19 Outbreak: Face Coverings Vs Surgical Masks Vs N95 Respirators

The Article also published in New Spotlight Nepal; July 13, 2020

“Coronavirus is smaller than the filtering pores on the N95 respirator, so you may wonder that the N95 respirator doesn’t work (can’t sieve out coronaviruses), right? Not exactly!”

Cloth Face Coverings

Cloth face coverings or masks are not manufactured to a recognized standard and they are not same as the surgical masks or respirators.

According to a research conducted in Nepal last year, the majority of locally available cloth face masks (having pore size 80 – 500 microns) may not be effective to avoid small particles (less than 10 microns). The study also revealed that repeated washing and drying of cloth mask deteriorates its efficiency.

Nonetheless, people who want to wear a face covering in public, workplaces and offices should be well encouraged to do so for the benefit of everybody. Several studies now indicate that wearing a mask, even a cloth face covering in the time of wide community spreads when physical distancing is tough to maintain, can create a physical barrier to the coronavirus.

A face covering can be very simple and may be worn in enclosed spaces as well as in crowded places where social distancing isn’t possible. While covering your mouth and nose, make sure you can talk with your face covering on and that it doesn’t irritate you. Otherwise you may be tempted to pull it out of place or touch your face and limit its effectiveness altogether.

face-covering

World Health Organization supports the use of cloth masks or face coverings to prevent the spread of coronavirus.

However, the benefit of using a cloth mask is limited and cannot be a substitute for other ways of managing risks in your homes and offices such as social distancing, reducing the number of people in the work area, minimizing time spent in contact, job rotations, increasing hand hygiene, and surface disinfection, etc.

Johns Hopkins Medicine also claims that wearing cloth masks or face coverings in public, when physical distancing can’t be maintained effectively, does offer protection against the spread of COVID-19.

The evidence suggests that wearing a face covering may not necessarily protect you, but it may protect others if you are infected and have not developed symptoms yet. On the other hand if you are healthy, a cloth face covering may as well protect you from larger infectious droplets from people around you.

Centers for Disease Control and Prevention reckons that a cloth covering may not protect the wearer, but it may keep the wearer from spreading the virus to others. That means “YOUR cloth face covering may protect THEM and THEIR cloth face covering may protect YOU”.

Let’s not forget that wearing a cloth face covering will especially help protect people who are at higher risk of severe illness from COVID-19 and workers who frequently come in close contact with other people (in shops, crowds, restaurants, etc.). Cloth face coverings will only prove to be effective in reducing the spread of COVID-19 when they are widely understood, accepted and practiced by all people in communities. 

Surgical Face Masks

Unlike face coverings, surgical face masks are manufactured to a recognized standard and can be effective in blocking splashes and large-particle droplets. Moreover, both face coverings and surgical masks do not provide complete protection from germs (viruses and bacteria) and other small contaminants in the immediate environment because of the loose fit between the surface of the mask or covering and your face.

You may notice that the edges of surgical masks are not designed to form a seal around the nose and mouth. 

surgical face mask

Surgical face masks are not to be shared and are normally designed to be worn in medical settings to limit the spread of infection. If worn properly, a surgical face mask is meant to help block large-particle droplets, splashes, sprays or splatter from reaching your mouth and nose. They also protect patients from the wearer’s respiratory emissions.

If your mask is damaged or soiled, or if breathing through the mask becomes difficult, you should discard it safely and replace it with a new one. Do not forget to wash your hands after handling the used mask.

Surgical-Mask-Effectiveness

The particle capturing capacity of the filter (nonwoven mats of fine fibers) used in modern surgical masks largely depends on its fiber diameter, porosity, thickness, etc. Due to the same characteristics, the performance of surgical face mask is superior to that of a cloth face covering. Nevertheless, the filtration mechanism of a surgical mask does not provide the wearer with a reliable level of protection from inhaling smaller airborne particles (less than 2.5 microns). Therefore the surgical face mask should not be considered a respiratory protection device.

N95 Respirators

A respirator, such as an N95 respirator, is a respiratory protective device designed to achieve a very close facial fit and very efficient filtration of small airborne particles. N95 respirators are capable of filtering out all types of small and large particles protecting you from exposure to biological aerosols including viruses and bacteria.

On the other hand, Surgical N95 respirators are commonly used in healthcare settings and are a subset of N95 respirators. A Surgical N95 respirator (also referred as a medical respirator) is recommended only for use by healthcare personnel who need protection from both airborne and fluid hazards such as splashes, sprays, etc.

female-nurse-wearing-green-n95-mask

The N95 designation means that when subjected to careful testing, the respirator blocks at least 95% of very small (up to 0.3 micron) particles. However, coronaviruses are even smaller in size (0.065–0.125 micron in diameter) and contain a single-stranded RNA as a nucleic material.

Therefore, the virus is smaller than the filtering pores on the N95 respirator, so you may wonder that the N95 respirator doesn’t work (can’t sieve out coronaviruses), right? Not exactly! 

To understand this concept first we need to know few basic principles pertaining to the behavior of viruses. “There is never a naked virus floating in the air or released by people”. The COVID-19 particle is indeed around 0.1 micron in size, but it is always enveloped by something larger. For example when a COVID infected person breaths, talks, coughs, etc., the exhaled viruses tend to attach to small droplets or aerosols (consisting of water, mucus protein and other biological materials from inside the infected person) which are all larger than 1 micron. Therefore, activities such as breathing, talking and sneezing generate particles around 1 micron in size, which can be efficiently collected by N95 respirator filters.

Although N95 respirator filter is 0.3 micron size, it works even better for particles smaller than the 0.3 micron threshold. This is because the N95 respirator filter does not only work by sieving out larger particles but also employ other mechanisms.

However counterintuitive it may sound, scientists have valid explanations for this. Firstly according to the principle of “Brownian Motion”, particles smaller than 0.3 microns move in an erratic or zig-zag kind of motion increasing the possibility of them getting trapped by the filtering fibers. Secondly due to the electrostatic attraction generated by the N95 respirator itself, particles smaller than 0.3 microns are drawn to the charged fiber and get stuck there, instead of just passing through the filtering pores. When the electrostatic charges are dissipated during extended usage and storage, the capability of stopping virus-sized particles (around 0.1 micron) diminishes. This is why repeated use of N95 respirator is not recommended.

The Article also published in New Spotlight Nepal; July 13, 2020

Also Read:

COVID-19: Know Your Risk Level

Covid-19 Pandemic: Safe Return to Work and Business Continuity

COVID-19: Disinfecting Your Homes and Offices

About Sustainable Safety Solutions, NEPAL

Environmental / Occupational Health & Safety for Planet, People and Profit.
This entry was posted in Businesses & Organizations, Environment, Health & Safety (EHS), Publication and tagged , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s